Skip to content

Book Review: Mere Churchianity by Michael Spencer

August 18, 2014

Mere Churchianity: Finding Your Way Back to Jesus-Shaped Spirituality. Michael Spencer. WaterBrook Press, 2010.


Something is very wrong in the church. People have been noticing, and getting more vocal about it lately the last few years. The Church hasn’t been matching up with what Jesus set it out to be. The Church has supplanted Christ as the ultimate interest of worship and concern. Hence the term Churchianity, which reflects this shift in mind.

It’s under this view that Mere Churchianity is written. Michael Spencer observed that what is on the label often doesn’t match up with what is being presented. He observes the number of “church leavers” that are going away in order to find Jesus – something with more integrity, authenticity, and honesty than the Jesus presented in most churches.

Spencer begins discussing the disconnect that the average church goer has with Jesus, due to the connection to their church organizations. People are conformed to them, and not to Jesus. Besides this, they become very prideful, unable to see their poor actions reflecting against Jesus despite the clear evidence witnessed by others.

The author points out that people often have a picture of God defined by their own ideas, concepts, and preferences. The answer is following Jesus Christ, One who can not be controlled or defined by others. This Jesus the one that we allow to shape us, not organizational policies or other things.

The book then presents a discussion of how a differing Jesus is presented today, resulting from the cultural confusion and church manipulation that has happened over the years. This has clouded the correct view of discipleship via rules, tradition, and culture. Spencer then points out that Jesus is not restricted to these churches or by these churches and is working in the world in His own will. The author’s answer to break out of this discipleship to church organization, reading the Bible for yourself is presented. Additional qualifications and conditions are often placed upon faith, making it works-based. This encouragement causes people to lie to themselves and others about the state of sin in their lives. Discipleship to church organization, dictated by programs and policies, is contrasted to discipleship to Jesus, which involves relationship and observation (learning by doing). In other words, Spencer points out that an association with a church does not a Christian make, no more than association with a garage makes you a car.

Spencer then describes the human element: The conditions of being involved in an organizational church setting involves a fear of individuality and encouragement of conformity. Those looking for authentic faith then admit defeat and leave rather to live life as a hypocrite. Discipleship looks very different in one who follows the organizational church than who follows the real Jesus.

The author covers a lot of ground in the 18 chapters he has written. Using an observational style, he will challenge you in a number of respects about the nature of church, versus the nature of real worship and service to Jesus. You will have a lot to think about in the course of this book, whether you agree or disagree with Spencer’s assessments. His assessments are often spot on.

Given Spencer’s observational style of writing and the amount of content, his book would benefit by organizing the content and making the points clearer. In addition, Spencer encourages a Personal Jesus based on worldly moral relativism at many points (for example p 76-77) in his book. It seems as many times, Spencer, as well as the previous author, fails to appreciate the gravity of sin and the nature of holiness that should exist in the life of the Jesus follower and in the life of the holy Church. As well, Spencer presents a nihilistic faith with respect to the sins of those who follow Christ (p 146).

Overall, this book is very valuable as an entry point to understanding some of the things that are wrong with the church. It echoes many of the points made here at the Society of Phineas and brought up some others for possible reflection. However, the lack of organization in the writing will cause you to have to read certain passages a number of times to understand the concept that Spencer is trying to relay. Spencer will give you much to ponder as well.

Rating: 7 out of 10.

Image Source:

  1. dvdivx permalink

    I think it’s telling that it’s the men leaving in droves not the women. Younger men (19-40) especially.

    What keeps me out is it’s all about the money and just feeling left out. The churches just seem to want money and if you are going through hard times not much is to be had. Most churches here just cater to the upper middle class and their problems. Ironic that Jesus was a carpenter yet few churches now would seem to welcome carpenters.

    In my personal case I’m also stuck in a dead marriage to a non-christian so that also adds to it. Sites like this talk about the problems of marriage 2.0 or finding a wife but nothing for those stuck in a marriage beyond the useless advice like “game your wife”. Life isn’t a frigging game and neither is marriage least of all if you have kids. Biblical divorce has not taken into account modern marriage and is in my opinion a giant failure of the church or even how to interpret scripture given the times we live in.

  2. @dvdivx
    Indeed. The woman is the one that is deceived (1 Tim 2:14), and the men are less likely to be able to be involved, so Churchianity caters to the women. This is why feminism was born in the church environment, and more so today feminism rules in the church.

    Then when you realize that these churches are literal businesses out for only numbers and nickels, there really is nothing left to consider with them. They have their organizational rules, and you better mold to them. Conform or else. This is a constant problem of mine in having to deal with churches. Jesus, Paul, and others we read of in the Scriptures would not be welcomed as leaders of the church, much less welcomed at all.

    As for marriage, there really aren’t a whole lot of solutions until people wake up and start acting against the causes of these things. The churches won’t act directly against these things, nor support men going through these things simply because they are invested in the government agenda. In short, modern marriage is so far afield of Scripture. While there are entities in the church with vested interests in this, there’s so many others who should know better that are still stoking the wicked fires.

    As for Game, that’s a whole other “Bloggian” thing that happens on these sites. There’s really no way to reconcile Game and Christianity (one is serving female tingles, the other is serving God), and it only feeds the problem as it’s just another way to supplicate to women instead of getting your life right before God. But as anything, a good lie always has elements of truth, and Game hits upon some truth – that doesn’t mean it’s a good idea. The answer is not to practice Game, but uphold Christianity.

    That said, I don’t know if you’ve run across these posts on here, but it’s my attempt to address the masculine drain that’s in society today. There’s one more post I haven’t gotten done simply because I haven’t found a good way to address it (Dominant and Submissive Frame), but hopefully you will see how I’ve addressed the matter.

    “Just Get It” Really Is The Answer
    Don’t Kiss Ass. Kick Ass Instead.
    The Nature of Genuine Manhood: Every Christian’s Battle

  3. JDG permalink

    Leaving church fellowship was / is not an option for me. Some years ago there were some wanted an egalitarian approach in church leadership while I and others pushed for the biblical model of leadership. We followed the teachings in the Bible. As the congregation and leadership matured, we began to align even more with the scriptures. If things had gone the other way, I would have searched until I found another congregation of bible believers, and had fellowship with them. Fellowship with other Christians is a must.

    From the review it sounds like I agree with Mr. Spencer, at least in part. Churches and entire denominations in western nations have become and are becoming apostate. Many already have left the Christian faith, and now many evangelical churches seem to be moving away from it as well. It’s tragic.

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. The intersection of Christianity and Churchianity is r(w)ife with problems | Empathologism

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 138 other followers

%d bloggers like this: